五常大米――增產量不增收入
tigaoliangjiashizhishangshitigaodijia,zheyangdehua,diduodenongminhuoyijiuduo,dishaodenongminhuoyijiushao。youyutudishinongyeshengchanzuihexindeyaosu,zhenduinongyedezhongzhongfuchizhengcehebutiedehaochuzuizhongdabufenluodaoletudisuoyouzheshouzhong。
最zui近jin幾ji天tian在zai東dong北bei參can加jia一yi個ge糧liang食shi論lun壇tan,順shun便bian實shi地di考kao察cha了le一yi下xia名ming聞wen天tian下xia的de五wu常chang大da米mi。參can觀guan了le五wu常chang水shui稻dao種zhong植zhi基ji地di,五wu常chang大da米mi加jia工gong企qi業ye,並bing品pin嚐chang了le真zhen正zheng的de五wu常chang大da米mi飯fan。
五常大米鬆軟可口,確實好吃。但也很貴,比一般優質大米要貴50%-100%。顯然,五常大米之所以貴,主要原因在“五常”二字上。因為水土和氣候,這裏種出的大米就是要比其他地方的好吃。五常大米相對於其他地區大米的“溢價”,是shi基ji於yu產chan地di,而er不bu是shi其qi他ta任ren何he因yin素su。這zhe意yi味wei著zhe五wu常chang大da米mi的de溢yi價jia最zui終zhong體ti現xian為wei五wu常chang土tu地di的de溢yi價jia之zhi上shang。我wo們men可ke以yi據ju此ci推tui斷duan,五wu常chang的de耕geng地di價jia格ge要yao大da大da高gao於yu全quan國guo其qi他ta地di區qu耕geng地di價jia格ge。也ye就jiu是shi說shuo,因yin為wei要yao付fu出chu更geng高gao的de地di租zu,在zai五wu常chang租zu地di種zhong植zhi五wu常chang大da米mi的de農nong戶hu收shou入ru並bing不bu一yi定ding比bi其qi他ta地di方fang高gao。增zeng產chan不bu增zeng收shou的de情qing況kuang可ke能neng由you此ci出chu現xian。
增產不增收,糧價上漲農民並沒有得到多少實惠,很多人為農民打抱不平。葉聖陶《多收了三五鬥》yiwenshidianxingdedaibiao。guanyunongminweishenmezengchanbuzengshou,jingjixueshangyouzhuwangmoxingyuyijieshi。henduoshihouzengchan,bingbushinongmindegonglao,ershiqitayinsudegonglao。zhongguoyoujuhuajiao“無功不受祿”。多收了三五鬥不是農民更勤快或者發明了新的種植技術,而是風調雨順、上(shang)天(tian)恩(en)賜(ci)的(de)結(jie)果(guo)。在(zai)市(shi)場(chang)經(jing)濟(ji)法(fa)則(ze)下(xia),風(feng)調(tiao)雨(yu)順(shun)導(dao)致(zhi)多(duo)收(shou)的(de)三(san)五(wu)鬥(dou)好(hao)比(bi)天(tian)上(shang)掉(diao)下(xia)的(de)餡(xian)餅(bing),它(ta)是(shi)砸(za)在(zai)了(le)作(zuo)為(wei)生(sheng)產(chan)者(zhe)的(de)農(nong)民(min)頭(tou)上(shang),但(dan)是(shi)實(shi)際(ji)上(shang)消(xiao)費(fei)者(zhe)也(ye)因(yin)此(ci)得(de)利(li):liangjiaxiajiangle。nongminjiaodemeiyouyinweiduoshoulesanwudouerhuodeduoshaoyichu,zheshizhanzaijiaohuandejiaodulaikaolvde。danshi,zhanzaishiwudejiaodu,nongminbijinghuodelegengduodeliangshi,tadejingyudedaolegaishan。raner,ruguotayaoxiangbazazaitoushangde“餡餅”賣掉而不是自己吃掉,他就必須遵守市場的供需法則。
當dang下xia中zhong國guo糧liang食shi的de增zeng產chan,依yi賴lai的de並bing不bu是shi農nong民min的de更geng勤qin勞lao。實shi際ji上shang現xian在zai種zhong田tian比bi以yi前qian輕qing鬆song多duo了le,種zhong植zhi技ji術shu比bi以yi前qian有you了le更geng大da的de提ti高gao,種zhong子zi比bi以yi前qian更geng高gao產chan,化hua肥fei農nong藥yao比bi以yi前qian更geng高gao效xiao。這zhe裏li麵mian除chu了le種zhong植zhi技ji術shu,其qi他ta幾ji項xiang都dou和he農nong民min無wu關guan。既ji然ran增zeng產chan主zhu要yao歸gui因yin於yu種zhong子zi、農藥、化肥,那麼增產的好處主要為種子研發者、農藥公司、化肥公司獲得,也就理所當然了。這與五常大米的溢價最終體現為五常土地的溢價、租地種的農民並沒有獲得多少好處是一樣的道理。
當dang前qian國guo家jia促cu進jin農nong民min增zeng收shou的de一yi大da措cuo施shi就jiu是shi不bu斷duan提ti高gao糧liang價jia,實shi際ji效xiao果guo看kan,這zhe幾ji年nian非fei城cheng郊jiao農nong民min的de收shou入ru提ti高gao也ye很hen快kuai。但dan是shi,收shou入ru的de提ti高gao不bu是shi因yin為wei種zhong糧liang更geng賺zhuan錢qian了le,而er是shi土tu地di因yin為wei糧liang價jia的de提ti高gao更geng值zhi錢qian了le。實shi際ji上shang,那na些xie外wai出chu務wu工gong的de農nong民min,沒mei有you種zhong一yi分fen地di,但dan是shi仍reng然ran可ke以yi通tong過guo不bu斷duan提ti高gao地di租zu來lai實shi現xian增zeng收shou。那na些xie在zai家jia種zhong糧liang的de農nong民min,其qi收shou入ru的de提ti升sheng很hen大da程cheng度du上shang是shi內nei化hua了le上shang升sheng的de地di租zu。如ru果guo獨du立li核he算suan地di租zu成cheng本ben,農nong民min真zhen正zheng的de來lai自zi於yu種zhong糧liang方fang麵mian的de收shou入ru提ti升sheng將jiang很hen有you限xian。
tigaoliangjiashizhishangshitigaodijia,zheyangdehua,diduodenongminhuoyijiuduo,dishaodenongminhuoyijiushao。youyutudishinongyeshengchanzuihexindeyaosu,zhenduinongyedezhongzhongfuchizhengcehebutiedehaochuzuizhongdabufenluodaoletudisuoyouzheshouzhong。在中國,由於土地相對分散,這種不均還不明顯。像美國這種土地高度集中的國家,農業補貼的好處絕大部分都被少數大農場主和農業公司得到,給農場主種地的農民獲益並不多。



